How the West Could Lose: A Timely Article by Daniel Pipes

Daniel Pipes asks a poignant question in his op-ed in today’s edition of the New York Sun: After defeating the fascists and the communists, can the West now defeat the radical Islamists?

He then raises the possibility that the ‘radical islamists’ might actually win where the West’s earlier rivals failed because according to him however strong the West is physically, its software has some very critical bugs like pacifism, self-hatred and complacency, which are being exploited to the hilt by the radical islamists with help from the inside by means of the Western leftist elite who he terms as the ‘auxillary mujahideen’.

He goes on to say that the very absence of an impressive military machine with the radical islamists comparable to that of the Axis powers or the one commanded by the Soviets during the cold war might give many Westerners, especially on the left, a feeling of disdain.

Whereas conventional war — men in uniform; ships, tanks, and planes; and battles for land and resources — is simple to comprehend, the assymetric war with radical Islam is elusive. Box cutters and suicide belts make it difficult to perceive this enemy as a worthy opponent. Senator Kerry and too many others dismiss terrorism as a mere “nuisance.”

He then lists down the advantages that the radical islamists, even without a formidable military, have in comparison to what the earlier Axis or Communist rivals of the West lacked inspite of commanding massive and capable militaries.

  • A religious appeal that provides deeper resonance and greater staying power than the artificial ideologies of fascism or communism.
  • An impressively conceptualized, funded, and organized institutional machinery that successfully builds credibility, good will, and electoral success.
  • An ideology capable of appealing to the masses from a wide varities of backgrounds in the Islamic world.
  • A nonviolent approach wherever necessary and
  • A huge number of committed cadres. If (radical) Islamists constitute 10 to 15% of the Muslim Population worldwide, they number some 125 to 200 million, a total far greater than all the fascists and communists(earlier rivals) , combined, who ever lived.


Filed under General, Geopolitics, International Politics, Terrorism

3 responses to “How the West Could Lose: A Timely Article by Daniel Pipes

  1. reads like the story of Indian secularism minus christian missionaries..

  2. Daniel Pipes declared on January 20th at the World Civilization Conference in London that Western civilization could only be better off after a total victory over “Barbarism”.

    Here are some figures of how the West will lose
    further and is it really worth to secure US’ economic and security interests.
    If it takes $8billion/month to fight in Iraq,
    how much money and lives are needed to fight Iran, Syria, Hezbollah and Hamas?
    If instead the money for Iraq i.e. $2billion/week or $11billion/hour was spent on winning hearts and minds
    a network of 365 x 24 x 4 years would have seen hospitals, clinics, bridges, schools, colleges and universities built.
    So are those who advocate escalating the conflict, actually serving America’s real interests?

  3. Jim, yes Iraq was a big mistake. The US should never have invaded it. But what has happened has happened.Now is the time to look ahead. Iraq is not Vietnam where the Americans had the luxury of walking away. The only way out of Iraq for America whether one likes it or not is Total Victory.

    And the Issue with the middle east is not lack of development. They are already flush with Oil money which they are not using wisely but diverting to fund extremism. So why not make sure that they spend their own money on hospitals, schools, clinics etc… instead of sponsoring terrorism?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s